Dear Bob,
The recent discussion with the Selectmen about protecting town-owned land,
specifically the Bragdon Farm, set me to thinking that others in town
probably have similar concerns. This open letter is an attempt to describe
the current ACC practice and procedures and respond to you about placing a
conservation easement on some of our town-owned properties.
Land Protection Goals - The ACC has a long-established Master Plan which is
consistent with the Town of Amherst Master Plan. With these goals before us,
we have identified several parcels of presently undeveloped land we think
would benefit the town to own. In choosing these we consider the following:
maintaining open space for its own sake, protecting present and future
drinking water sources, connecting existing conservation parcels to reduce
habitat fragmentation, encouraging diversified habitats for diversified
species, aesthetics of viewsheds and roadways, potential for non-damaging
passive recreation by residents and environmental education possibilities.
Land Management Objectives and Authority - The ACC was created in 1966 when
Amherst voters adopted state law RSA 36-A permitting towns to have
conservation commissions. Other laws that affect the commission operation
and funding have since been adopted. Under RSA 36-A:4, the ACC is empowered
to receive gifts of money and property in the name of the Town to be managed
and controlled by the commission.
Many mechanisms are provided for acquisition including: gifts, purchase,
grant, bequest, easement, covenant or contract. The ACC is authorized to
maintain, improve, protect, limit the future use or otherwise properly
utilize open spaces and other land and water areas. (While the RSA does not
specifically refer to recreation on conservation land, it has been and is the
ACC position that non-damaging personal recreation that gets folks out into
the woods is beneficial to the conservation effort.)
Ensuring the Conservation Goal - Robert Frost writes in Mending Wall that
"Good fences make good neighbors." Just as a carefully crafted stone fence
avoids future squabbles between neighbors, so careful thought to long-term
land protection at the time of transfer can avoid misunderstandings down the
road. What may seem obvious to commissions or voters today may not be
understood or desired by the public years, even decades from now.
Deeds or other weighty documents should clearly specify the intent of the
parties that the land be dedicated forever to conservation goals. Deeds for
recent ACC acquisitions incorporate the words, "(seller) grants to the Town
of Amherst, NH to be managed by and through the Amherst Conservation
Commission pursuant to NHRSA 36-A a certain parcel of land (described)."
This is deemed to express the parties' wishes for "perpetuity and a day", as
you have phrased it.
Another vehicle for long-term protection is a conservation easement. Such an
easement may be created by the owner at any time or the donor of a parcel
prior to transfer. Easements are recorded and may include specific
covenants. They may also allow certain activities which are not contrary to
the overall intent of the easement. For instance, if a conservation easement
were in effect for the Bragdon Farm and a future commission or the voters
decided to make a buck by mining gravel from the old ski slope, the holders
of the easement could bring court action to halt the removal.
This brings up the question of who holds the easement and assumes the right
to defend it. A conservation commission may purchase or hold an easement.
This is appropriate for land that is only protected by the easement (not held
in fee). For land owned by the Town for which the deed does not specify
management by the ACC for conservation purposes, an effective way to ensure
perpetual protection is to add the tier of a conservation easement. In this
situation, the easement could be held by a land trust, the Fish and Game
Department or the Society For the Protection of New Hampshire Forests.
Cases In Point - The Forest Society is currently working with several
municipalities to place public lands under protective easements. Dublin,
Lebanon, Nashua and Sullivan County are some of the governmental bodies
effecting easements with the Society. Amherst could join the growing list.
The ACC believes conservation easements on the Bragdon Farm and several other
parcels would be effective insurance that the historical votes of the Town
and its conservation commissions stand up to future tests.
I hope these non-legal notes help you in your effort to ensure that the
intent of your wonderful gift is not lost. The ACC is ready to help if
further information or steps are desired.
Bruce B. Beckley
Last Update: